AVOID (TRAP) due to low 34 pace and weak foot 2 — severely limits movement and distribution. Skip this card if looking for a reliable keeper; better options exist in all budget brackets.
Competing in Major League Soccer.
| Pace | 34 |
| Shooting | 22 |
| Passing | 19 |
| Dribbling | 19 |
| Defending | 15 |
| Physical | 49 |
| Skill moves | 1★ |
| Weak foot | 2★ |
| AcceleRATE | CONTROLLED |
John McCarthy's standout attributes are Physical (49) and Pace (34).
This card scores 52.5 in our meta engine, placing it in X tier. Best suited to the GK - Goalkeeper role. Check the full meta tier list

See evo paths for John McCarthy in the FC 26 Evo Builder. Stack stages, preview the upgraded card, and find the meta-friendly chain.
Use John McCarthy as a base in the FC 26 Squad Builder. Test formations, chemistry, and links across all 30 FC 26 formations.
John McCarthy sits in X tier according to our meta rating engine and performs best in the GK - Goalkeeper role, based on stats, PlayStyles and real match impact rather than overall rating alone.
John McCarthy carries 2 PlayStyles on this card, which unlock in-game animations and stat boosts tied to specific actions like crossing, finishing or tackling.